Skip to content
Winter Storm GearField guide
Guides menu67 guides

Stay warmAnswer9 sources

Warmest Winter Coats: What Fill Power and Ratings Really Mean

What makes a winter coat warm: fill power, fill weight, shell and length, plus how to read a maker's temperature rating before you trust the number.

We earn from qualifying purchases through links on this page.

A person kneeling in the snow in a dark thigh-length parka with a fur-trimmed hood, taking a photo among frosted trees

Quick reference4 facts

Fill power measures (Outdoor Research)Down quality: the cubic inches of loft from one ounce of down
Common outdoor range (Switchback Travel)About 600 to 900 fill
Lightweight down jacket (Switchback Travel)Might have about 3 ounces of fill; a midweight 5 or 6
Canada Goose TEI 5Rated by the maker for -22°F and below
On this page (4 sections)
  1. What does fill power measure on a winter coat?
  2. Is higher fill power always warmer?
  3. How do temperature ratings on winter coats work?
  4. What else changes how warm a coat feels?

The warmest winter coats combine enough fill, good coverage and a shell that stops wind and wet. Fill power measures down quality, not warmth on its own, so look for the amount of fill as well. Temperature ratings come from each maker, so they work best for comparing coats within that maker’s range.

This page explains the numbers. For the bigger picture, start with how to choose a winter coat.

What does fill power measure on a winter coat?

Fill power measures how much space a set amount of down fills. Outdoor Research describes it as “the cubic inches of loft one ounce of the specific down produces,” so one ounce of 800-fill down lofts to 800 cubic inches, as Switchback Travel explains.

Put another way, a higher number means the same loft from less down, which is why high-fill coats can feel light for how warm they are. Outdoor Research also says jackets with lower-quality down are often less expensive, though heavier and less compressible.

Helly Hansen and Switchback Travel give different ranges:

Fill power Who says what
300 to 900 Helly Hansen’s stated range for parkas, with 400 to 500 the most common rating
500 or lower Switchback Travel says some casual jackets dip this low
600 to 900 Switchback Travel’s main range for outdoor gear

Down parkas

Shop down parkas

Opens eBay in a new tab. Check condition, seller feedback and returns.

Is higher fill power always warmer?

Higher fill power does not always mean a warmer coat. Outdoor Research says a higher rating “doesn’t necessarily mean one jacket will be warmer than another,” and that a jacket with lower-quality down can be warmer simply by holding more of it.

Fill weight, the amount of down in the coat, is the other half of the answer. Switchback Travel says a typical lightweight down jacket might have three ounces of fill and a midweight jacket five or six. It adds that serious winter jackets and parkas can have much more.

The comparison is simple when one number matches. Six ounces of 800-fill will be substantially warmer than three ounces of 800-fill, Switchback Travel says, but six ounces of 600-fill against three ounces of 900-fill “becomes trickier.”

Fill weight can be harder to find than fill power. Switchback Travel says it isn’t as readily available from many makers, though a maker’s chat representative can often tell you. L.L.Bean’s page for its Baxter State Parka, for example, lists 650-fill down and a weight of 3.7 lbs. for the coat, without an ounce figure for the down.

How do temperature ratings on winter coats work?

A temperature rating is a maker’s own guide to the conditions a coat is meant for. Canada Goose publishes a five-point Thermal Experience Index, where it says TEI 1 is the lightest insulation and TEI 5 is the warmest parkas it makes:

Canada Goose rating Temperatures the maker states
TEI 1 41°F to 23°F
TEI 2 32°F to 5°F
TEI 3 14°F to -4°F
TEI 4 5°F to -13°F
TEI 5 -22°F and below

That scale belongs to one brand. Winter jackets have no standardized temperature test like the ISO rating on sleeping bags, Switchback Travel says, so don’t read one maker’s rating against another’s. L.L.Bean’s Baxter page, for instance, gives fill power, fit and a layering note (“Best with heavyweight layer”) rather than a temperature.

What else changes how warm a coat feels?

Wind, wet and coverage can matter as much as what is inside the coat. Down lags behind synthetic insulation when wet, Switchback Travel says, so a high fill number may not help in sleet. Our parka vs puffer guide compares down with synthetic.

A few other things play a part:

  • What you wear underneath. Helly Hansen says your layers affect how warm a parka feels.
  • How much of you it covers. Switchback Travel says women’s parkas may reach the knees or beyond, while many men’s models stop just below the seat. Our guides to women’s winter coats and men’s winter coats cover length and fit, and our plus-size winter coats page covers sizing past the chart.
  • How the down was stored. IDFL says compression and storage can reduce fill power, and that jackets may drop 10 to 40 percent. It says wearing the jacket helps, and so can a tumble dryer or a wash.

Wind chill is about exposed skin

The National Weather Service bases wind chill on heat loss from exposed skin, and says cold is dangerous with or without wind. At 0°F with a 15 mph wind, the wind chill is -19°F, and exposed skin can freeze in 30 minutes. NIOSH tells workers in the cold to protect the ears, face, hands and feet, so a warm coat is not enough on its own.

Frequently asked questions

What is the warmest type of winter coat?

Outdoor Research says the warmest down jackets are built with high fill power down and a heavier down weight. Coverage adds to that: Switchback Travel says parkas are the better choice for more warmth and coverage, though they are also heavier and more restrictive.

Is 650-fill down warm enough for winter?

It can be, because fill power is only part of the answer. L.L.Bean lists 650-fill down in its Baxter State Parka, and Outdoor Research says a jacket with more of a lower-fill down can be warmer than one with less high-fill down. Check coverage and the shell as well.

Can I compare temperature ratings between brands?

Be careful doing that. Switchback Travel notes that winter jackets have no standardized rating method like the ISO rating on sleeping bags. Each rating comes from the maker that publishes it, so compare coats within one maker's range.

Why does my down coat look flat?

Compression and storage can reduce loft. IDFL, a down testing lab, says jackets may drop 10 to 40 percent in fill power from compression, shipment, storage and assembly, and that wearing the jacket, air circulation and moisture help it recover.

Sources

  1. What Does Down Fill Power Mean?Outdoor Research
  2. Down Fill and Insulation ExplainedSwitchback Travel
  3. Fill Power Questions and AnswersIDFL
  4. How to choose a parkaHelly Hansen
  5. Thermal Experience Index (TEI)Canada Goose
  6. Men's Baxter State ParkaL.L.Bean
  7. Best Winter JacketsSwitchback Travel
  8. Understanding Wind ChillNational Weather Service
  9. Cold and Work: Types, Causes, PreparationNIOSH, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention

Filed under Stay warmPart of Winter Coats and Jackets: How to Choose the Right One

Affiliate disclosure

Winter Storm Gear is reader-supported. Some links on this page are affiliate links: when you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an eBay Partner, we may be compensated if you make a purchase through our links. Commissions never decide what we recommend or how we rank it. Listings and prices come from our partners and change often, so check the price, condition and seller on the retailer's page before you buy. Read how we make money.