Snow and iceAnswer16 sources
Do Ice Cleats Work? Coils, Studs and Spikes for Icy Sidewalks
What the research says about ice cleats and winter falls, how coil, bead and spike cleats differ, and which style suits sidewalks, driveways and trails.
We earn from qualifying purchases through links on this page.

Quick reference4 facts
| Evidence (JAGS trial, 2005) | Fall-prone older adults wearing Yaktrax Walkers had 19 outdoor falls, against 43 in usual footwear |
|---|---|
| Coil cleats | Light, for packed snow and town walking; the basic style can slip off on hills |
| Spike cleats | Short carbide spikes for icy sidewalks; longer steel spikes for mountain trails |
| Indoors | Take cleats off before tile, wood or sealed concrete: they slip on hard floors |
On this page (5 sections)
Yes, ice cleats work: in a 2005 trial, fall-prone older adults wearing slip-on cleats had 19 outdoor falls over a winter, against 43 in ordinary winter footwear. For sidewalks and driveways, a light coil cleat or a short-spike model over your boot is enough. Longer spikes suit trails and steep ice. Take any cleat off before walking indoors.
What the research says about ice cleats and falls
The clearest evidence for ice cleats comes from a randomized trial in the Journal of the American Geriatrics Society. Fall-prone older adults in the northern United States wore the Yaktrax Walker over their usual winter footwear outdoors through the winter of 2003 to 2004 and kept a daily fall diary. ScienceDaily’s report of the study says the cleat group recorded 19 outdoor falls, against 43 in the group wearing usual winter footwear. Indoor slips and falls were similar in both groups.
Larger studies are less clear-cut. Swedish researchers looked at municipal programs that handed out free ice cleats to residents aged 65 and over. One study found that a typical program raised self-reported cleat use by about 7.5 percentage points. A second estimated a drop in ice-related fall injuries, but the confidence interval included zero. The estimated effect was larger, and clearer, in towns that handed out more cleats.
Read together, the studies suggest cleats help the people who actually wear them. The hard part is getting them on before the first icy step.
Coil, bead and spike cleats compared
Ice cleats come in a few main styles, and each grips a different surface. Most stretch a rubber or elastomer band over the boot, then add metal underfoot.
| Cleat style | Example | Best surface | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Steel coils | Yaktrax Walk | Packed snow, town sidewalks | Can slip off when walking uphill; snow can build up in coils |
| Coils plus a top strap | Yaktrax Pro | Packed snow, ice and slopes | The strap adds a step when putting them on |
| Steel beads on cable | Yaktrax Diamond Grip | Mixed ice and softer snow | More cleat than a short walk to the car needs |
| Short carbide spikes | Kahtoola NANOspikes, Yaktrax Spikes | Icy streets, sidewalks, driveways | Made for town ice, not steep trails |
| Longer steel spikes on chains | Kahtoola MICROspikes | Trails, mountain ice, packed snow | More than most sidewalks need |
Yaktrax describes the basic Walk as 1.2 mm steel coils on an elastic band, aimed at pedestrians heading to work, school or the mailbox. The Pro uses slightly thicker 1.4 mm coils, and Advnture notes that its strap across the top of the foot holds it in place on inclines, where the Walk can slip off. The Diamond Grip swaps coils for case-hardened steel beads with edges that grip in all directions, and Yaktrax says the design is self-clearing, so snow does not build up.
For bare, icy pavement, short spikes are the specialist choice. Kahtoola says its NANOspikes carry ten tungsten carbide spikes per foot, designed for hard surfaces and icy streets and sidewalks, and that the carbide resists wear from pavement. MICROspikes go the other way: twelve 0.41-inch stainless steel spikes per foot, which Kahtoola pitches for ice and packed snow in mountain terrain.
Ice cleats and traction aids for boots
Live listings, shown by eBay
Opens eBay in a new tab. Check condition, seller feedback and returns.
Which ice cleats suit sidewalks and driveways
Sidewalks and driveways mix packed snow, glare ice and patches of cleared pavement, so a low-profile cleat works best there.

Coil cleats cover packed snow on a walk to the mailbox. For glazed ice on concrete, Yaktrax pitches its Spikes model, with seven tungsten carbide spikes under the ball and heel, for icy sidewalks, parking lots and driveways.
For shoveling, a full-foot cleat that covers heel and toe gives grip wherever your weight lands as you push. Heel-only cleats are a work-site option: Ergodyne’s TREX 6315 strap-on heel model leaves the midfoot open for driving or ladder climbing, which also leaves the front of the foot without grip.
Size the cleat to your boot rather than to your shoe size. An insulated snow boot is bigger than a sneaker, and Yaktrax recommends buying one size larger than your normal shoe size for oversized shoes or boots. Our snow boots section covers the boots themselves.
How to wear ice cleats safely
Ice cleats make icy ground safer, but they are only safe outdoors. Cotswold Outdoor says Yaktrax are not safe on smooth indoor surfaces, and the FSHD Society passes on its members’ warning that cleats cause slips and falls on hard floors. Put them on at the door and take them off before tile, wood, linoleum or a store’s sealed concrete floor.
Take them off at the door
Cleats do not replace careful walking. University safety offices, including UNC Charlotte and the University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science, teach the “penguin walk” on ice:
- Point your feet slightly outward.
- Take small, shuffling steps.
- Keep your knees slightly bent and your center of gravity low.
- Keep your arms out to the sides and your hands out of your pockets, so you can catch yourself.
Clearing ice so you need cleats less
Good traction underfoot works best on a path that is also cleared and treated. Our guide to ice melt versus rock salt explains which deicer works in deep cold and which is kinder to pets and concrete. For the snow on top of the ice, a snow pusher can clear light snow quickly; see how to choose a snow shovel. Ice cleats also make a practical present: they appear in our winter storm gifts list for dog walkers. More snow and ice guides are in the snow and ice section.
Frequently asked questions
Do ice cleats really prevent falls?
The best-known trial suggests they help. In a 2005 study in the Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, fall-prone older adults wearing Yaktrax Walkers had 19 outdoor falls against 43 in the group wearing usual winter footwear. Swedish research on free cleat programs found more cleat use and a smaller, less certain drop in ice-related injuries.
Can you wear ice cleats on concrete?
Some are built for it. Kahtoola says its NANOspikes are designed for hard surfaces, with tungsten carbide spikes that resist wear from pavement, and Yaktrax pitches its Spikes model for icy sidewalks, parking lots and driveways. Longer trail spikes such as MICROspikes are made for ice and packed snow in the mountains.
Should I take ice cleats off indoors?
Yes. Cotswold Outdoor says Yaktrax are not safe on smooth indoor surfaces, and the FSHD Society passes on its members' warning that cleats cause slips and falls on hard floors. Take them off at the door before stepping onto tile, wood or sealed concrete.
Which ice cleats are best for shoveling the driveway?
A full-foot cleat that stretches over your snow boot suits most driveway work, since you mix packed snow, ice and cleared pavement. Yaktrax recommends going one size larger than your shoe size for oversized shoes or boots, so the cleat stays on while you push a shovel.
Sources
- Anti-Slip Device Reduces Falls in Older AdultsScienceDaily
- A simple gait-stabilizing device reduces outdoor falls and nonserious injurious falls in fall-prone older people during the winterJournal of the American Geriatrics Society (PubMed)
- Ice cleat distribution programmes and ice cleat use among older adults: repeated cross-sectional evidence from 63 municipal interventions in SwedenInjury Prevention (PubMed Central)
- Quasi-experimental evaluation of municipal ice cleat distribution programmes for older adults in SwedenInjury Prevention (PubMed Central)
- Walk Traction DeviceYaktrax
- Pro Traction DeviceYaktrax
- Diamond Grip Traction DeviceYaktrax
- Spikes Traction DeviceYaktrax
- NANOspikes Footwear TractionKahtoola
- MICROspikes Footwear TractionKahtoola
- The 12 types of Yaktrax: which is best for frozen pursuits?Advnture
- YaktraxCotswold Outdoor
- Tips and tricks: STABILicers light ice cleatsFSHD Society
- Ergodyne launches new strap-on heel ice traction deviceISHN
- Walk Like a Penguin in the Ice and SnowUniversity of Maryland Center for Environmental Science
- Walk like a penguinUNC Charlotte Environmental Health and Safety
Filed under Snow and icePart of Snow and Ice Removal: Shovels, Snowblowers, Ice Melt, Roof Rakes