Skip to content
Winter Storm GearField guide
Guides menu67 guides

Stay warmHow-to6 sources

Sorel Snow Boots: Caribou, Joan of Arctic and Explorer Compared

How Sorel's Caribou, Joan of Arctic and Explorer boots differ, what Sorel temperature ratings mean, and how reviewers say the boots fit.

We earn from qualifying purchases through links on this page.

A tan lace-up winter boot stepping into deep snow

Quick reference4 facts

CaribouRemovable 9 mm felt liner in a rubber shell; Sorel rates it to -40 degrees
Joan of ArcticRemovable 6 mm felt liner and a 12-inch suede upper; Sorel rates it to -25°F (Treeline Review)
Temperature ratingsMaker claims; there is no standardized rating system for footwear (Switchback Travel)
FitReviewers find the Caribou roomy and the Explorer small and narrow
On this page (5 sections)
  1. How Sorel snow boot lines differ
  2. What Sorel temperature ratings mean
  3. Sorel boot sizing and what to check
  4. Sorel felt liner care and weight
  5. Who Sorel snow boots suit

Sorel’s best-known snow boots split into three types: the Caribou, a heavy pac boot with a thick removable felt liner for deep cold; the Joan of Arctic, a tall women’s boot with a thinner liner; and the Explorer line with built-in insulation. Sorel’s temperature ratings are its own claims, and fit varies by model.

How Sorel snow boot lines differ

Sorel’s snow boot lines differ mainly in how the warmth is built in. The Caribou and Joan of Arctic are two-piece boots, a waterproof shell with a removable felt liner, as Switchback Travel describes them. The men’s Explorer Waterproof uses 100 g of built-in insulation instead.

Boot How it is built Warmth details Fit reports
Caribou Nubuck leather upper on a vulcanized rubber shell, seam-sealed, with a snow cuff (Altitude Sports, Treeline Review) Removable 9 mm recycled felt liner; Sorel rating of -40 Roomy; feels about a size large to some reviewers
Joan of Arctic 12-inch waterproof suede upper on a rubber base; laces only water resistant (Treeline Review) Removable 6 mm recycled felt liner; Sorel rating of -25°F About a half size up for thick socks (Treeline Review)
Explorer (men’s waterproof) Suede upper with a waterproof bootie and an EVA sole with a rubber center (Altitude Sports) 100 g insulation; no temperature rating on the retailer page Reviewers say small and narrow

Treeline Review notes the Joan of Arctic is modeled on the Caribou, with a thinner liner. Sorel also sells “Next” versions of the Joan with shorter shafts and 100 g insulation, so check the exact model name before you compare.

What Sorel temperature ratings mean

A Sorel temperature rating is the maker’s own estimate, not the result of a shared test. Switchback Travel says there is no standardized rating system for the warmth of footwear, and that it always assumes brand ratings are overly generous.

Reviewers bear that out. Treeline Review’s testers were comfortable in the Caribou to at least -20°F, against Sorel’s -40 rating. OutdoorGearLab could not verify -40°F in the women’s Caribou but stayed warm at -20°F. The -40 figure is the same in Fahrenheit and Celsius, which is why some retailers print it both ways.

Read a Sorel rating as a ranking

Use the ratings to rank Sorel boots against each other: a -40 Caribou is warmer than a -25°F Joan of Arctic. Then allow a margin, especially if you will stand still at a bus stop or on a sideline. Our snow boot buying guide explains how insulation and activity change how warm a boot feels.

Sorel boot sizing and what to check

Sorel boot sizing changes from model to model, so the advice for one boot does not carry to the next. For the Caribou, OutdoorGearLab found the women’s version felt a size larger with a voluminous fit, while Treeline Review says Sorels run a bit large but still advises your true shoe size. For the Joan of Arctic, Treeline suggests about a half size up for thick socks and notes the boot is stiff and hard to pull on. Explorer reviewers on Altitude Sports report the opposite problem: small and narrow.

Before you keep a pair, check these at home:

  1. Wear the thickest winter socks you plan to use. Switchback Travel says a winter boot should take them without pinching.
  2. Lace up and walk on stairs. Your heel should stay down and your toes should not touch the end.
  3. Pull out the liner on a Caribou or Joan and check that it sits flat with no folds.
  4. If the length is right but the boot pinches across the foot, look at our guide to wide snow boots.

Sorel felt liner care and weight

Sorel felt liners can be pulled out to dry, which helps when feet sweat on a long day. Treeline Review and OutdoorGearLab both describe the Caribou liner as removable and washable, and Switchback Travel notes that Sorel sells replacement liners. A boot dryer speeds up drying overnight.

Weight is the trade-off. Switchback Travel lists the Caribou at about 4 pounds 10 ounces, and Treeline Review calls it bulky, heavy and clunky for multi-mile hikes. OutdoorGearLab says it is too much boot for low snow.

Sorel winter boots on eBay

Shop sorel winter boots

Opens eBay in a new tab. Check condition, seller feedback and returns.

Who Sorel snow boots suit

Sorel’s felt-lined pac boots suit people who shovel, stand outside or walk through deep, unplowed snow. For cleared sidewalks and commutes, a lighter insulated boot is easier to wear all day. Our guides compare more options: women’s snow boots, men’s snow boots for deep snow and fur-lined boots. Every boot guide is in the snow boots section.

Frequently asked questions

Are Sorel boots really warm to -40 degrees?

Sorel rates the Caribou to -40, which is the same in Fahrenheit and Celsius. Reviewers at Treeline Review and OutdoorGearLab stayed warm to about -20°F but could not confirm -40. Switchback Travel notes that footwear has no standardized rating system.

Do Sorel Caribou boots run big?

Reviewers say so. OutdoorGearLab found the women's Caribou felt about a size large, while Treeline Review says Sorels run a bit large but still advises your true shoe size. Try them on with your winter socks before deciding.

Can you wash Sorel boot liners?

The felt liners in the Caribou and Joan of Arctic are removable. Treeline Review and OutdoorGearLab describe them as washable, and Switchback Travel notes that Sorel sells replacement liners.

Which Sorel boot is best for deep snow?

The Caribou is the deep-snow pac boot of the three: a rubber shell, a thick felt liner and a snow cuff. Reviewers call it heavy and clunky for long walks, so lighter boots suit cleared sidewalks better.

Sources

  1. Sorel Caribou ReviewTreeline Review
  2. Sorel Caribou (Women's) ReviewOutdoorGearLab
  3. Sorel Men's Caribou Waterproof BootsAltitude Sports
  4. Sorel Joan of Arctic ReviewTreeline Review
  5. Sorel Men's Explorer Waterproof BootsAltitude Sports
  6. How to Choose Winter BootsSwitchback Travel

Filed under Stay warmPart of Snow Boots: Warmth, Waterproofing, Fit and Grip on Ice

Affiliate disclosure

Winter Storm Gear is reader-supported. Some links on this page are affiliate links: when you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an eBay Partner, we may be compensated if you make a purchase through our links. Commissions never decide what we recommend or how we rank it. Listings and prices come from our partners and change often, so check the price, condition and seller on the retailer's page before you buy. Read how we make money.