Skip to content
Winter Storm GearField guide
Guides menu67 guides

Stay warmHow-to2 sources

Winter Gloves and Mittens: Waterproof, Insulated and Touchscreen

How to choose winter gloves or mittens for shoveling, storms and daily wear: mittens vs gloves, waterproof shells, insulation, liners, fit and touchscreen tips.

We earn from qualifying purchases through links on this page.

Two people in winter coats talking outdoors, breath visible in the cold air, one wearing knit gloves

Quick reference4 facts

Warmest shapeThe National Weather Service says mittens are better than gloves
Dry mattersWet gloves pull heat from the hands; keep a spare dry pair
FitNIOSH warns tight gloves can raise frostbite risk by limiting blood flow
LayeringA thin liner under a shell glove or mitten adds warmth and a backup layer
On this page (6 sections)
  1. Should you pick mittens or gloves?
  2. What makes a winter glove waterproof and warm?
  3. Why does keeping gloves dry matter?
  4. How should winter gloves fit?
  5. Are touchscreen gloves worth it?
  6. When do heated gloves make more sense?

Winter gloves and mittens keep hands warm by trapping heat and blocking wind and wet. For the most warmth, choose mittens, which the National Weather Service says are better than gloves. For grip on a shovel or steering wheel, choose an insulated, waterproof glove. Fit loosely enough for blood flow, and keep a spare dry pair.

Should you pick mittens or gloves?

Mittens and gloves trade warmth for dexterity. The National Weather Service’s cold-weather advice is short: “Mittens are better than gloves.” Fingers held together in one compartment warm each other and have less surface to lose heat from.

Gloves win when you need your fingers: gripping a shovel handle, fitting tire chains, working zippers or buckles. Some designs split the difference:

Style Warmth Dexterity Fits
Mitten Highest Lowest Waiting, walking, very cold days
Glove Lower Highest Shoveling, driving, chores
Lobster or three-finger mitt Between the two Between the two Cold days with some handwork
Convertible (flip-top) mitten High with cover on Fingers free with cover off Switching between tasks
Liner glove Low alone High Under a shell, or alone on mild days

What makes a winter glove waterproof and warm?

A warm winter glove usually has three parts: an outer shell, insulation and a lining. Each one does a different job.

  • Shell. The outer layer blocks wind and snow. Leather and coated synthetic fabrics shed water; a waterproof membrane inside the shell keeps melted snow out.
  • Insulation. Synthetic fill, down or fleece traps warm air. Many shoveling and work gloves use synthetic fill, which is common in gear meant for wet snow.
  • Lining. A soft inner layer adds comfort and some warmth. A removable liner can dry overnight on its own.

A long gauntlet cuff that goes over the jacket sleeve keeps snow from falling in at the wrist. A short cuff that tucks under the sleeve works better for driving.

Insulated winter gloves and mittens

Shop winter gloves and mittens

Opens eBay in a new tab. Check condition, seller feedback and returns.

Why does keeping gloves dry matter?

Wet gloves draw heat away from hands far faster than dry ones. The National Weather Service tells people in winter weather to “Keep your skin dry,” and NIOSH’s cold stress guidance says to keep gloves from getting wet and to carry spare gloves in case a pair does.

In practice that means a few habits:

  1. Bring a second pair for long jobs like clearing a driveway after a big storm.
  2. Take gloves off indoors and dry them away from direct high heat, which can stiffen leather.
  3. Stop and swap if your hands sweat heavily inside a heavy glove; a lighter pair plus breaks may work better than one very thick pair.

Our snow shovels guide covers pacing and breaks while clearing snow, which also keeps gloves from soaking through.

A pair of brown fur-lined mittens resting on snow
Mittens keep the fingers together, which the National Weather Service says is warmer than gloves.Photo: Jurgis Stonkus / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0

How should winter gloves fit?

Fit matters more than most buyers expect. NIOSH cautions that gloves that are too tight can restrict blood flow to the hands and raise the risk of frostbite. A glove that pinches the fingertips or squeezes across the knuckles when you make a fist is too small.

Try gloves on with any liner you plan to wear. There should be a little space at the fingertips and room to curl your hand around a handle without the shell pulling tight. Sizing varies by maker, so check the size chart on the product listing, usually measured around the palm.

Layering helps here too. NIOSH describes cold-weather clothing as working in layers, and a thin liner under a roomy shell glove or mitten gives you a warm combination plus a dexterous layer to use alone for a quick task.

Are touchscreen gloves worth it?

Touchscreen gloves have conductive thread or patches, usually on the thumb and index fingertip, so you can tap a phone screen without bare skin. They are handy for checking a weather alert or a map. Most touchscreen gloves are thin knit or light fleece, so on a very cold day treat them as a liner and wear a mitten or shell over them.

When do heated gloves make more sense?

Battery-heated gloves suit people whose hands stay cold even in good insulated gloves, or who spend hours outside. They add weight, cost and charging. Our guide to heated jackets, vests and gloves covers how they work and what to check before buying.

Heated gloves and apparel

Shop heated vests, jackets and gloves

Opens eBay in a new tab. Check condition, seller feedback and returns.

For a cheaper boost, a disposable warmer tucked into a mitten adds hours of heat; see our guide to disposable hand and toe warmers.

Layers, snow pants and heated gear are in our winter clothing section.

Frequently asked questions

Are mittens warmer than gloves?

Yes, as a rule. The National Weather Service says mittens are better than gloves, because fingers kept together share warmth. Gloves give more grip and finger control, so many people keep both.

What gloves are good for shoveling snow?

A waterproof, insulated glove with a grippy palm suits shoveling, since you hold a handle and handle wet snow. Bring a spare dry pair for long sessions; damp gloves lose warmth quickly.

Should winter gloves fit tight?

No. NIOSH cautions that gloves that are too tight can restrict blood flow and raise the risk of frostbite. Leave a little room at the fingertips, especially if you wear a liner underneath.

Do touchscreen gloves work well in the cold?

Touchscreen gloves have conductive patches, usually on the thumb and index finger, so you can use a phone without taking them off. They tend to be thinner, so they suit short trips or work as a liner under a warmer shell.

Sources

  1. Winter Weather Safety: DuringNational Weather Service
  2. Personal Protective Equipment for Cold StressNational Institute for Occupational Safety and Health

Filed under Stay warmPart of Winter Clothing: Snow Pants, Fleece-Lined Pants and Heated Gear

Affiliate disclosure

Winter Storm Gear is reader-supported. Some links on this page are affiliate links: when you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an eBay Partner, we may be compensated if you make a purchase through our links. Commissions never decide what we recommend or how we rank it. Listings and prices come from our partners and change often, so check the price, condition and seller on the retailer's page before you buy. Read how we make money.